28th Feb 2007
Susie speaks out for scrotums, librarians, and professionalism
This is why I *heart* Susie Bright, a hero of mind ever since I saw her present at Wesleyan when I was an undergrad. Not to beat a dead horse, but I want to share just an excerpt of her post about the The Higher Power of Lucky bochinche over the word “scrotum.”
You Say Scrotum, I Say Hoo-Ha
[c/o Susie Bright's Journal, posted 20 feb 2007]
The Times’ sample of quotes reveal a group of obvious religious conservatives who betray more about their own ignorance, phobias, and lack of library professionalism than they do about the state of the English vocabulary— in literature or social life.
Anyone who says that “male genitalia are not in quality literature” needs to have their resumé examined. What’s more, this is hardly the first time that the word “scrotum” has appeared in children’s books. Think again, Ms. Bosman!
Children’s libraries, librarians, and authors are being smeared in stories like these. Children’s Lit is a field that includes the greatest writers of all time, speaking on every topic, with every nuance of language. I’m sure E.B. White is turning over in his grave to contemplate this canard, one that Templeton the Rat wouldn’t scratch his testes with.
…other bits you should go read, then…
Most librarians are not tight-lipped prudes, they’re courageous front-liners on First Amendment issues. Most families are nonchalant about the daily-observed behavior of their dogs and cats. Parents— who are not in the grips of fundamentalist fever— believe it’s helpful for young people to know the correct terms for their own body parts, be they a nose, elbow, vulva, or scrotum.
It’s really, really hard to make the argument that not buying the book is a “budget decision” or a “collection decision” when buying everything on the Newbery list is standard operating procedure for most (I say most, not all) school and public libraries, often beating out non-award-winners in the purchasing decision process.
Much like kids using the internet at the library, or just using the library in general, it’s up to parents and guardians to police and moderate content consumption for their kids, not me or any other librarian. Like the Allston librarian interviewed by NPR about the whole mess, I would no sooner warn a parent ahead of time that the word scrotum is on the first page than tell a teenager not to read Go Ask Alice. I also think it might help if some librarians didn’t have such a trigger finger for trying to avoid controversy.
And that’s all I hafta say about that. Dead horse beaten. 
This is why I *heart* Susie Bright, a hero of mind ever since I saw her present at Wesleyan when I was an undergrad. Not to beat a dead horse, but I want to share just an excerpt of her post about the The Higher Power of Lucky bochinche over the word “scrotum.”
You Say Scrotum, I Say Hoo-Ha
[c/o Susie Bright's Journal, posted 20 feb 2007]
The Times’ sample of quotes reveal a group of obvious religious conservatives who betray more about their own ignorance, phobias, and lack of library professionalism than they do about the state of the English vocabulary— in literature or social life.
Anyone who says that “male genitalia are not in quality literature” needs to have their resumé examined. What’s more, this is hardly the first time that the word “scrotum” has appeared in children’s books. Think again, Ms. Bosman!
Children’s libraries, librarians, and authors are being smeared in stories like these. Children’s Lit is a field that includes the greatest writers of all time, speaking on every topic, with every nuance of language. I’m sure E.B. White is turning over in his grave to contemplate this canard, one that Templeton the Rat wouldn’t scratch his testes with.
…other bits you should go read, then…
Most librarians are not tight-lipped prudes, they’re courageous front-liners on First Amendment issues. Most families are nonchalant about the daily-observed behavior of their dogs and cats. Parents— who are not in the grips of fundamentalist fever— believe it’s helpful for young people to know the correct terms for their own body parts, be they a nose, elbow, vulva, or scrotum.
It’s really, really hard to make the argument that not buying the book is a “budget decision” or a “collection decision” when buying everything on the Newbery list is standard operating procedure for most (I say most, not all) school and public libraries, often beating out non-award-winners in the purchasing decision process.
Much like kids using the internet at the library, or just using the library in general, it’s up to parents and guardians to police and moderate content consumption for their kids, not me or any other librarian. Like the Allston librarian interviewed by NPR about the whole mess, I would no sooner warn a parent ahead of time that the word scrotum is on the first page than tell a teenager not to read Go Ask Alice. I also think it might help if some librarians didn’t have such a trigger finger for trying to avoid controversy.
And that’s all I hafta say about that. Dead horse beaten. ![]()
Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off





